A favorite argument in the anti-hospital contingent is that the US infant mortality rate is SO BAD, that it is worse than “third world” countries.
There are many things wrong with the above argument, not the least of which is that the US “has more infant mortality than most other countries, including 3rd world.” You’d think maybe this was one lone internet warrior, but the argument is everywhere.
My favorite part is that both of these women claim that anyone who doesn’t accept what they say just hasn’t done the research. Anyone want a drink?
Before I say anything else, let me mention that “third world” is an outdated term, and we now use “developing countries” to describe, well, developing countries. But, as I often do on this blog, I digress.
There are two things wrong with this argument. First, it simply isn’t true. The US infant mortality rate, while higher than it should be, in my opinion, is nowhere near the rates of developing nations. Let’s have a look at this map:
Huh. Would you look at that. We’re in the same basic category as all of Europe, Japan, South Korea, Australia…
A graph is a little more your style? Well, here you go:
Again, there is always improvement to be made when it comes to any kind of mortality, and the US rate is higher than many developed nations (The WHO says the American rate is a 5, and countries like Canada, the UK, New Zealand, and Ireland, are a 4 and many Scandinavian countries are a 3. Countries like Poland and Hungary are a 6.), but the United States is nothing like a “third world” country when it comes to infant mortality. We’re far lower than the world average.
The other — larger — problem with this argument, is that infant mortality is not a measure of maternity care, it is a measure of pediatric care. It covers babies from birth through a year of age. The correct statistic to use is perinatal mortality, which is through 27 days of life. So how does US perinatal mortality measure up?
Have a gander. I used the data from the list of countries that the World Bank considers “high income or developed” to make my graph (I left out Trinidad and Tobago, as the World Bank has given them an asterisk and their PMR is significantly higher than all other nations on the list including, of course, the United States):
The US has numbers equal to or better than 18 of the 31 nations, including Great Britain, France, Finland, Denmark, the Netherlands, etc. In the category of perinatal mortality, the US does much better in comparison to the rest of the developed world than they do with infant mortality. Again, there is always room for improvement when it comes to death rates, but it is a flat out lie that the United States is on par with developing nations in this regard.